A couple of nights ago Rowan wanted to watch some space shuttle launch footage on youtube. (This is one thing he and Gram love to do together.) It was easy to find some footage; I just searched for "space shuttle launch" and up came hundreds of video clips I could click. From the small still images, Rowan pointed out, "I want this one." I clicked it and we watched a minute or two of space shuttle countdown, takeoff, and rocket booster separation. When the first clip ended he chose another video to watch. A few minutes in, we were on the third video selection and Rowan was totally engrossed while I was having a side conversation with Tom. I noticed out of the corner of my eye that the footage looked lower quality than the previous two launches, definitely not widescreen format, so I thought it might be an older shuttle. I looked away again and said something else to Tom, and then the sound of a man's voice in a radio transmission grabbed my full attention. I heard, "Roger, Challenger..."
I gasped audibly.
Fumbled with the keyboard to stop the video.
Felt tears filling my eyes.
Finally found the "back" button on the browser, cutting the video off.
Rowan didn't notice my panic, and mercifully he went off to play in his room without a word from me. Tom continued what he was doing several feet away. The whole situation evoked a depth of emotion in me that was absolutely startling.
I sat there on the couch remembering vividly the day in Mrs. O'Quinn's first grade class that we watched the Challenger take off. A television on one of those big tall rolling carts had been brought in from the library so we could watch. We watched with excitement as the shuttle soared high, but then we saw streams of smoke going in directions that didn't make sense. We listened to the announcers' confused words while he tried to figure what happened. I remember the words "major malfunction" coming from the television as our teacher, with tears in her eyes, leapt to turn off the broadcast. Later, I remember finding out what had really happened, though I don't remember when I found out. I also don't remember if I had any emotional reaction, though I suppose I must have. I remember knowing that human beings, including a teacher, had died. I knew it could have been a kindergarten teacher from my school who had applied to the program and was admitted as an alternate, leaving school early the year before to train.
My surprise at my emotional response to seeing a few seconds of the Challenger launch is almost equaled by my surprise at the "lesson" I have taken away from it.
This experience gave me a deeper appreciation for Mrs. O'Quinn, who shepherded our first grade class through that traumatic day of the Challenger disaster. I also thought of Mrs. Dasher, my English teacher in high school, who was with us on the day that we saw the Oklahoma City bombing on television. Looking back, both of these teachers did the best they could to explain something horrible to young people who shouldn't have had to grasp horrible things. I remember knowing my whole class was sad, and I remember feeling comforted and secure by my teacher in both instances. By that standard, these two women did a really good job. I have tried to think back to how my parents discussed these tragedies with us, and I'll tell you, I can't remember. I am sure we did discuss them, and I know that throughout my childhood I respected my parents' viewpoint, so I would have listened to what they had to say. But I just can't remember it now, which probably isn't surprising because a dinnertime conversation is far more likely to be forgotten than the indelible moment when a child witnesses something that she has never seen before, and that has deep ramifications. The thing is, I feel pretty safe in going out on a limb and saying that neither Mrs. O'Quinn nor Mrs. Dasher shared the viewpoints of either of my parents at the time, nor the viewpoints I hold now, on faith, politics, or social justice. For many people I know, the idea that someone who doesn't share their viewpoint should have to explain something life-altering to their child is terrifying. And a week ago, I might have said it's terrifying to me too. But now, it isn't.
In those few seconds of panic while I tried to turn off the video to prevent my preschooler from seeing the violent and tragic death of human beings, I realized that no matter how much I think I know, I don't know how to explain something like that to Rowan. No matter how much I love him, and of course I love him more than words could ever express, I can't fix the terrible things he might encounter in this world. All I can do is my very best to teach him about Love and the faith that guides our lives...and we do that to the best of our ability every single waking minute in a multitude of "mundane" ways. In a moment of crisis or tragedy, there may be lessons to be had about mercy, justice, theology, philosophy, politics, and any number of other things, but those lessons are for later. The moment calls for a person who cares, honestly, about my child, and is willing to act as best she knows how to show him that he is cared for as he learns to cope.
I haven't asked them, but my mom and dad probably realized that in order to send me to school (a public school where I thrived, by the way), they had to put this kind of trust in teachers like Mrs. O'Quinn or Mrs. Dasher, people they barely knew. I know Mom and Dad were vigilant in case it seemed like a teacher wasn't worthy of that trust, but the default choice was to extend it. I'm glad they decided to take this leap.